THOM BELL AND LINDA CREED: LOVE IS THE MESSAGE
Songwriting
credits in today’s music industry read like names of prestigious law firms. It’s
not uncommon to list five or six names as co-writers. Factor in samples/
interpolations and the number grows---a far cry from the days when writing and
production teams were crews who worked in twos (and threes).
Ask your
typical music aficionado these days to run down their short list of great
songwriting tandems and they just might stop at LA and Babyface or Jam and
Lewis and overlook the prolific genius predating contemporary R&B.
Producer/arranger Thom Bell and lyricist Linda Creed helped brand the Sound of Philadelphia as the preeminent music during the first half of the 1970s. They would weave a string of Top Ten million-sellers into the tapestry of the Stylistics' three gold albums---The Stylistics (1971) Round Two (1972) and Rock and Roll Baby (1973).
Anchored by lead tenor Russell Thompkins' creamy falsetto, Bell and Creed’s songs were played on R&B, pop, and Easy Listening radio formats and covered by everyone from Marvin Gaye and Diana Ross to Englebert Humperdink to Johnny Mathis.
R&B was four years removed from Otis Redding’s soulful bluster and was deep in the midst of James Brown’s chest-beating machismo. Thompkins’ vocals would come off as virile to some. Music critic Robert Christgau branded the Stylistics as authentic modern-day castrati raising the bar for “absurd high seriousness of the love-man mode into an asexual spirituality that the Delfonics only hinted at and the country-rock harmonizers only fake and exploit”
Philly soulmates the O’Jays and Harold Melvin
and the Blue Notes delivered potent send-ups
I Miss You and Sunshine on the Live in London and Golden
Gate Groove: Live in San Francisco albums featuring spoken rap interludes with sly
carnal references.
O'Jay Eddie Levert’s playful suggestion to “charge” his lover
into sexual submission and Melvin’s offer to sneak back into his lost lover’s life disguised as the milkman leaving “four quarts instead of two” were worlds away from Bell and Creed's depictions of “candy land and fairy tales” sung by the Stylistics on Betcha By Golly Wow So were Blue Note lead singer Theodore
Pendergrass’ forceful reprimands (“Sit down!”) on Be For Real.
When it was time for Thompkins to deal with his lady---he took a different approach thanks to Bell and Creed. You’ll Never
Get to Heaven If You Break My Heart finds Thompkins gently admonishing his
lady for being “mean and cruel” and reminding her to “follow the Golden Rule." Instead of Levert’s sexy remedy for his moody
woman (“I know what your problem is baby/“go on upstairs/and put some of that
black sexy lace”), Thompkins serenade celebrates rather than
seduce: “You’re
as right as rain/softer than a flower/
sweet as marmalade”
Visionary
icons-in the-making Maurice White and George Clinton weren't fans of
stand-up vocal groups like the Stylistics or Philly Soul orchestration
either. When devising his concept for
Earth Wind and Fire, White chose not to model his band after what he called "middle of the road doo-wop groups" of the period he branded as
“the era of the military lineups."
As a former doo wop singer-turned-P-Funk front man, Clinton dismissed symphonic soul in favor of his brand new funk: "You know, violins, big productions, disco, the Teddy Pendergrasses, it all sounds like white pop music of the 50s. A lot of it is cool, but it's still just a rehash of what white America did...."
Criticisms
aside, Black listeners born in the 1950s and 1960s who came of age during the
1970s were feeling the male and female vocalists and standup groups of the era. Young brothers from Hip hop's first generation were
especially intoxicated by this potent elixir of flamboyant cool, sexiness and
refinement.
In a 1988 interview for Spin
Magazine urban taste maker Fab Five Freddy waxes poetic on a golden era:
''There was a time when a b-boy may want to
get together with his girl and go to a club where you can chill, sip a little
Dom Perignon, a little caviar, munch a little fried chicken or whatever may be
and cool out with his girl. And he would take off those sneakers and put on a
pair of Clarks or British Walkers. When I was a kid, we had the Stylistics and
Blue Magic and if you went to see those people, that was how you dressed. You
didn't put on sneakers to hear the Stylistics. You put on something kind of
fly..
In his 2001 memoir Life and Def, rap mogul Russell Simmons offers up his own
assessment of the era:
" People don't understand
this but the falsetto, crying singers were the most ghetto singers back then.
For all their talk of love, there was something pimp-like, manipulative and fly
about that sound. Like one of my favorite records, the Delfonics' Hey Love
where the lead singer is begging for that ass in a roof-scratching
falsetto...."
Harlem hustler-turned-crooner Oran Juice
Jones’ 1986 single The Rain---a conceptual nod to great Temptations/Dramatics/Barry
White-Love Unlimited singles I Wish It
Would Rain, The Rain and Walking in The Rain With One I Love and
vocal throwback to Dramatics and Blue
Magic high tenors Ron Banks and Ted Wizard Mills---zoomed up the charts thanks
to Juice’s infamous monologue that checked
his cheating lover (“Don’t touch that coat!!”) and recalled the velvety plushness of Isaac Hayes,
Chi-Lites and Harold Melvin/BlueNotes records.
An old You Tube clip of Jones' Soul Train appearance finds him
singing the praises of classic soul to Don Cornelius: “The average person who's into Hip Hop---during the day they may listen
to LL or Run or Kurt......but when they go home they can't keep banging
it....you gotta chill sometimes, cool out...listen to the Moments, the
Delfonics, Blue Magic...."
Across dimly lit basements, cellars and rec-rooms, sexy slow drags radiated from the slow-burn of Bell’s pristine productions. Creed’s lyrical affirmations of love transported couples to a romantic oasis that was a world away from the one outside of Young Black America's window.
THE PRODIGY |
"I find that going into
the studio with a lot of electronics, you waste more time. I’ve gone into the
studio with cats who said, “Play so and so. That’s enough.” “But I didn’t play
nothing.” “Well, we can sample the rest.” “Look man, turn the machine off. By
the time you get finished sampling this thing, I could have played the thing 50
times already.” I come from another school where you put the music down and you
play it. You either play it right or you get out. That’s the reason I practiced
for years and years, to learn my craft. That’s nerve-wracking to me.....
New
Jack Swing King Teddy Riley said it best: there are beat-makers and then there are
producers. Thom Bell was a producer. Rarely mentioned with the likes of Stevie
Wonder, Marvin Gaye, Maurice White and Barry White, he might trump them all in
terms of self-contained ability. Sounds sacrilegious? Let’s put things in
perspective. The genius of these 70s giants is undisputed---but the truth is---fingerprints
of collaboration are all over their signature work. You
can’t mention Wonder’s musical maturation without acknowledging the role synth
pioneers/engineers Robert Margouleff and Malcolm Cecil played in shaping
Wonder’s sprawling ideas into a cohesive package of five straight groundbreaking
albums.
Gaye’s
prescription for his chronic writer’s block was his pairing with Ed Townsend
and Leon Ware---key collaborators helping him deliver love-and-war magnum
opuses Let’s Get It On, I Want You and Here My Dear.
Until White enlisted mentor
Charles Stepney---a producing/arranging/composing prodigy who rivaled Bell’s talents, Earth Wind and Fire was just another fledgling rock/funk act instead of the sophisticated R&B super group they would become under his tutelage.
Conductor/arranger Gene Page’s string arrangements gave Barry White’s love themes their plush symphonic vibe. Bell did it all himself. Write. Produce. Play. Arrange. Sing. A master of efficiency, he recorded multiple albums worth of material for his artists at one time while mapping out a creative direction for the next ones coming up.
Conductor/arranger Gene Page’s string arrangements gave Barry White’s love themes their plush symphonic vibe. Bell did it all himself. Write. Produce. Play. Arrange. Sing. A master of efficiency, he recorded multiple albums worth of material for his artists at one time while mapping out a creative direction for the next ones coming up.
He
wrote out music charts out for session musicians and recorded vocal parts on
individual portable tape recorders for singers to learn their notes. These days
we salivate over never-heard musical outtakes, lost tapes, black albums and
hidden gems laying around in vaults. That didn’t apply to Thom Bell. Quality
over quantity was the rule. It was the reason he was ranked top arranger and
producer in industry trade magazines for consecutive years and win the very
first Grammy Award for Producer of the Year in 1975.
Bell’s
rumbling piano chords kicked off the OJays’ menacing Back Stabbers (1972).
Harold Melvin and the Bluenotes' I Miss
You (1972) featured his plush melancholy backdrops framing Baby Lloyd
Parks' Philly falsetto and Pendergrass' roaring baritone to perfection. Besides
handling arrangements for partners Gamble and Huff, Bell scored a music hat trick reaching success with three different
groups: The Delfonics, The Stylistics and The Spinners.
Born into a musical family, Bell cut his teeth
on classical music. As a child, his ability to hear music in his head and vocally
imitate the sounds was met with skepticism by teachers who misdiagnosed it as a
mental disorder. Instead of falling for the Herodian attempt designed crush
Bell's prodigious genius, his West Indian mother (a concert pianist herself)
set them straight---"If he says hears music, that's what he hears!"
Moving from piano, drums, guitar, horns, harmonica and accordion his rapid
musical progression was elevated by his exposure to exotic instruments by
international exchange students visiting his home.
Long before the Beatles and
Maurice White picked up Indian sitars and African kalimbas, Bell had access to
them as a child growing up in West Philadelphia in the late 1940s and early
50s.
When
a fledgling group was brought to him, William Hart's falsetto/tenor vocals and
lyrics and Bell's string-laden classical production were the foundations for
proto-Philly Soul classics La-La-La Means I Love You (1968) Ready or Not Here I Come (Can't Hide
Love) (1969) and Didn't I Blow Your
Mind (This Time) (1970).
At
twenty, he moved to New York City in hopes of finding a career conducting orchestras,
but even his musical sophistication was no match for the racial politics of the
day. Returning to Philly, he established himself on the local music scene while
teaching himself to arrange music by checking out music theory books in the
library.
Bell's
encyclopedic music knowledge served him well. Before larger recording budgets
afforded him the ability to hire classically trained musicians, he played every
instrument himself. Ideas may have taken shape in Bell's blue songwriting room
(with matching piano) but first he had to hear an artist in his head:
“Let me get down to the
specifics of what makes you who you are without the song. I can tell if you
have a naturally great voice or whether it’s something the engineer has done,
the producer has done, or it’s the kind of mic that you’re using. When I work
with you, I got to be able to hear you in my mind. I’m singing to myself and I
can swear I sound just like you. And if I can sound like you, then I can write
for you.”
At a Bell session, the musicians and the
artists were required to stick to the script. When Spinners flashy front man
Phillipe Wynne went into his bag of vocal tricks to launch the trademark
ad-libs endearing him to audiences, Bell let him take flight. As soon as Wynne
came down to earth, then Bell turned
on the tape, coaxing him to play it straight on emotional numbers like Sadie (1975).
Bell's
work ethic was relentless. In his 2015 book Growing
Up in The Sound in The Philadelphia,
songwriter Bruce Hawes recalls his initial meeting with Bell who quickly paired
him with Creed---tearfully pushed to her creative brink finish a lyric after being
charged with writing no less than six songs in one day for a Johnny Mathis project.
Compared
to producers who remained in the protective pocket and worked primarily with
hot artists, Bell thrived on the challenge of orchestrating career makeovers
for languishing acts like the Spinners: (
"Don’t bring ’em to me unless they’ve got bombs. That’s my job, to keep
you from getting bombs”.). Ever confident in his abilities, Bell promised
each member a Cadillac---10K in early 70s dollars----if he didn't give the
five-man group a hit the first time out. He would give them five.
Bell explained the music to the artist,
teaching them the song's elements by singing it to them. Vocals were put to tape and they learned the
song before Bell rehearsed them on piano. Singers never heard the actual music
until it was time to record---creating an anticipation that inspired the
stellar vocal performances that we hear on those records today.
Years before legendary record man Clive Davis made his bones transforming Black female singers into crossover superstars, he wasn't so forward thinking in terms of recognizing the scope of Bell’s mastery when he approached Davis wanting to produce pop star Mathis ("Thank you very much. You’re a nice producer, but for black music"). Undaunted, Bell reflected on Davis’ underestimation of his gifts:
Years before legendary record man Clive Davis made his bones transforming Black female singers into crossover superstars, he wasn't so forward thinking in terms of recognizing the scope of Bell’s mastery when he approached Davis wanting to produce pop star Mathis ("Thank you very much. You’re a nice producer, but for black music"). Undaunted, Bell reflected on Davis’ underestimation of his gifts:
"He made that mistake that a lot of
people make. Don't get the hue of the skin mixed up with the kind of music I
make...I gotta tell you, Bacharach and David are two of the greatest writers.
They did classical things, and that's what I always wanted to do. People told
me, 'Black people don't dig that kind of music.' I'd say, 'What do you mean?
I'm black and I dig it. There's got to be more of me out there than just me.'
When it comes to music, the hue of skin has nothing to do with likes or
dislikes. Music is not something you wear. Music is something you feel."
Aware
of vocal limitations of other group members, Bell employed background singers to
strengthen their vocal parts in the studio. A picture on the back of the
Stylistics’ Round 2 album shows Bell
working with the group in Sigma Sound Studios.
In reality, Creed, Bell and PIR
members usually sang on the records. Bell never made it public ("the
public doesn't need to know stuff like that") and preserved the group's
reputation as silky soul front runners. He also paid musicians salaries above
union scale and gifted them gold records on hits they played on.
THE POET |
In the hip 1970s, Linda Creed could have been mistaken for Bell’s romantic interest instead of his prolific songwriting partner. She sometimes was mistaken for a Black woman (just as Blue Magic songwriter Bobby Eli was) assumed based on her musical affiliations. Creed was the daughter of a French Jewish insurance salesman who emigrated to Philadelphia. Raised in Philly's Mt. Airy section, Creed was raised on Connie Francis' confectionery pop but soon gravitated to R&B when she discovered Smokey Robinson and The Miracles as a teenager:
A 1973 Jet magazine issue features a rare photo of Thom Bell and Linda Creed together.
|
"Up until the age of fourteen, I only
knew about WBIG, here in Philadelphia which played Lipstick On Your Collar and
stuff like that. I listened to it but it didn't kill me. Then one day I was watching the Ed Sullivan Show---and I saw
a guy named Smokey Robinson and the Miracles
who I'd never heard of and he was
singing you You Really Got A Hold On Me and I was prostrated to the floor.
That's music !....
There was something about it
that just captured me! (But) Smokey's lyrics were spellbinding. I loved them.
He said things simply, but it carried over into your emotions. I think if
anybody I've taken my style of songwriting from; my style is possibly derived
from Smokey...."
R&B
newcomer Creed made up for lost time and delved into Black music head first.
Like white Middle-American teens tapping into Black music's life force via remote
radio stations back in the fifties, she tuned in to Philly's Black radio
stations WDAS and WHAT---weak signal and all.
Unlike the kids who had to sneak
and listen to ebony-hued urban sounds away from disapproving parents, Creed's
cultural pursuit was conducted out in the open. She purchased seminal Black
rock and roll records to study and attended jazz festivals. High school at
all-black Germantown High was just around the corner and she wanted to be
ready. Just as partner Bell faced ridicule for his prodigious gifts as a child, the self-proclaimed "weird child" faced encountered similar reactions from her white friends because of her musical
obsession:
'' Everybody laughed at me.
My friends didn't quite understand. I mean they would like a song, but I got
into the bassline...From the moment I got into music, and particularly R&B,
people laughed. I became very black oriented because to know something you must
experience everything and only through feeling that experience can you know
what you're talking about. I was scorned all the way...."
Harboring ambitions of being a singer, Creed held
down a gig as a secretary for a New York music publishing firm while writing
poetry on the side. She recorded a few sides produced by Bell that went nowhere.
Through an encounter with funk giant Sly Stone, she picked up songwriting tips
that would shape writing style.
With ruined vocal chords and no prospects,
Creed moved back to Philadelphia and reunited with Bell eventually forming a
partnership. Success came quick. In '69 Creed wrote her first song. By '71 she
wrote her Top 40 first hit. A year later, she had her first million seller.
Unlike
great writing teams like Motown’s Holland-Dozier-Holland who worked out songs
together, Creed and Bell’s unorthodox system transformed Stylistics albums into
literal greatest hits packages. In past interviews, Bell and Creed described their
unique work style:
"She
couldn’t stand sitting around waiting for me to come up with melodies and
things. So, she’d go home, and I’d call when it was ready. I would call her the
next day and make a tape of it, give it to her and whatever I wrote–if I wrote
the first verse, or sometimes I didn’t write anything but the hook of the song,
like “Betcha By Golly Wow” or “People Make the World Go ‘Round” or something
like that. Then I’d give it to her and the next day, she’d have it.”
Bell
and Creed’ collaborative approach but worked to perfection. "I’d be working on one note for an hour
or two hours. She’d say, ‘Bell, you take so long!’ It wasn’t too long to
me....We made a vow I won’t call you until I want you to write lyrics, you
won’t call me unless you want me to write a melody. When I was finished with
those melodies, I’d call Creed. Bang! The next day, the lyrics were done….
During
an interview with Bruce Pollock for his book 1975 In
Their Own Words, Creed provided her own take: "Originally, we'd sit down together, and Tommy would play a melody
and I'd write a line at a time or wherever I could fit it in and then I'd go
back and polish it up. As we became more professional and as I began to get a
method to my madness, I would just get a tape of the melody from Tommy and then
I would go home and take a week or whatever to work on it... So I generally sit
with the song about two or three days, playing it over and over, listening to
it while making the bed or cleaning up or whatever.....To me if you're going to
state something, state it so it’s understandable....I write pretty basic
lyrics, really basic emotions that would be pretty easy for anyone
to identify with, but at the same there's a certain depth to hem...
Sometimes they clashed over ideas. Bell admitted Creed initially rejected his concept for Betcha By Golly Wow. Creed acknowledged she wasn't "knocked out" by Ghetto Child: ("It took me forever to do because I didn't like the melody").
Sometimes they clashed over ideas. Bell admitted Creed initially rejected his concept for Betcha By Golly Wow. Creed acknowledged she wasn't "knocked out" by Ghetto Child: ("It took me forever to do because I didn't like the melody").
When Bell came
up with lyrical ideas for The Fat Man, a tune dedicated to his overweight son
that eventually became The Rubberband
Man---Creed thought it was
"ignorant" and "anybody
could write it." Bell stood firm: "Too bad. That's the way I like
it." Creative differences aside, the songs were destined to become hits.
Big ones.
Songs
like People Make the World Around
(1972) showcased Creed's flair for light social commentary but as usual, love
was the primary topic in a Creed lyric. The titles said it all. Stop, Look, Listen (To Your Heart). I'm
Stone in Love with You---all inspired by her relationship with husband Stephen Epstein. Her first
million-seller You Are Everything (1972) was written during her
engagement to Epstein:
"I don't know, I think
it was automatic....In the first year of our marriage, I watched this girl
write four or five songs about us. And me, being a promotion man going around
the country promoting songs about my life and watching them become No. 1
records, my hair used to stand up on my arm. It gave me chills..... For
example, in 'Stoned in Love with You,' she wrote, 'Overnight sensation, drive a
big, expensive car.' Well, my first week in the record business, the flamboyant
promotion man that I was, I bought a long, all-white Cadillac with a sun roof.
When our neighbors had a fight, Linda wrote 'Break- up to Make-up.' She said,
'They're just breaking up to make up, that's all they do.' Name any song and I
can tell you what was going on in our life at the time....."
Creed’s
couplets in I Don't Want to Lose You (1975)
tugged at the heart strings:
"Who do you think you
are/ who do you want to be/you're the only one that really know
Maybe you’ll be surprised/
after your search is through/when you find you've just been chasing you."
Believe me I understand/ the
vision of your mind/but I'm so afraid that the girl you'll find may not need a man like me."
1975's
Living Just a Little, Laughing Just a
Little continues Blue Magic's melancholy carnival theme heard on ‘74's Sideshow and Three Ring Circus. Backed up by Bell's typical epic pageantry: sweeping piano chords and
French horns sounding uncannily like The Murder of Don Fanucci Theme from The
Godfather II---Creed puts her spin on Smokey's tearful clown
concept:
"Laugh as the funny man
cries/though his makeup is smeared
Laugh at his comical tears/as
he thinks of the years
Laugh everyone at the fool
/with his heart in his hand
Still he can't quite
understand/ that he's less than a man
Lost somewhere deep in his
shell/there's an ember of pride
Watch how he tries hard to
hide/that he is dying inside"
Creed's writing could be animated and jovial. Rock and Roll Baby (1974) spins a tale
of little Joey---the young "tootsie roll soul" born in a theater in
Bluefield, West Virginia who wore little white orthopedic shoes and never sang
out of tune.
Creed's lyrics to her much maligned The Rubber Band Man (1976) jumped right
off the page straight into a half a million ears on its way to another gold record.
On the Spinners 1974 hit I'm Coming Home
and Ronnie Dyson's 1973 breakout One Man
Band (Plays Alone), Creed explores failure, disappointment and personal
setbacks---similar concepts featured in Motown-Philly predecessors Where Are All My Friends (1974), I Could Never Love Another (After Loving
You) (1967) and Back Stabbers (1972).
Instead of Gamble and Huff's brooding production and dark story
lines, Bell and Creed crafted bouncing melodies
and animated lyrics with a whimsical twist. Where lead singers Teddy Pendergrass and David Ruffin were cast as tortured souls betrayed by fairweather friends and
and tormented by lost love, I'm Coming Home and One Man Band find Phillipe' Wynne
and Ronnie Dyson reflecting on their trials and tribulations with sage-like
introspection and optimism---thinly veiled conceptual metaphors for Creed’s own
resolution in the face of her own personal experiences. Her failed singing
career was the inspiration for Home:
"I'm really not
ashamed/to have the leave the city/and I don't want nobody to show me pity
Cause I had more than I can
stand/and back home I can be a better man
I can rearrange my life/might
even find me a pretty wife"
One Man Band's lyrics were especially personal:
"Each man is the master
of his own destiny/and I can surely best determine what is right for me/If I
had the chance to change my life/I wouldn't dare /doin'okay/livin' this
way"
Bell
and Creed's prolific composing and songwriting, signature kept the Stylistics
ahead of the pack of stand-up vocal groups: "Because
guys were starting to catch up to my sound, I said, “that’s okay, that’s all
right.” I started digging deeper into my own background and deeper into the
symphonic orchestra..."
Just four years into their fertile
partnership, Creed was diagnosed with breast cancer. She was just 26 years old.
Bell was by her side when doctors told her she would never have children. In
Creed fashion, she put her pen to paper, crafting an ode to her mentor and
friend. It became the Stylistics biggest
hit:
"My love,
I'll never find
the words my love, to tell you how I feel my love.
Mere words,
could not explain, precious love,
You held my life
within your hands, created everything I am,
Taught me how to
live again.
Only you, Cared when I needed a friend
believed in me through thick and thin,
This song is
for you, filled with gratitude and love
God bless you,
you make me feel brand new,
For God blessed me with
you, you make me feel brand new,
I sing this
song 'cause you, make me feel brand new.
Described by Creed as “different from what people
think of in R&B" You Make
Me feel Brand New --marked the end of Bell and Creed’s association with
the Stylistics.
Bell turned his full attention to the Spinners and drafted a new team of writers to help execute the creative vision he had for the group. Creed pitched in, writing lyrics to some of their most memorable songs. Five consecutive gold albums (three went to #1) and a string of hit singles later, the Spinners went from journeyman act to pick of the litter of 70s vocal groups.
Bell turned his full attention to the Spinners and drafted a new team of writers to help execute the creative vision he had for the group. Creed pitched in, writing lyrics to some of their most memorable songs. Five consecutive gold albums (three went to #1) and a string of hit singles later, the Spinners went from journeyman act to pick of the litter of 70s vocal groups.
At
the peak of Creed’s creative powers, Stephen Epstein lobbied for his wife to
become an equal partner in Gamble-Huff Music. Instead she received a contract
revision granting her a larger writer percentage. Parting ways with her Philly
Soul colleagues, she headed for California to pursue writing and producing
opportunities.
In ’77 she scored a major hit, co-writing The Greatest Love of All, the moving theme song for Muhammad Ali
biopic The Greatest. She would later take a five-year hiatus from
the industry and move back East to the Philly suburbs to raise her family.
Creed
could afford to take time off. She’d earned nearly half a million dollars in
song royalties by ‘75. She had a beautiful home in the Philly suburbs with
enough land to fulfill her dream of raising horses. Instead of a life of
opulence, things were low-key at 1425 Schirra Drive. Weekends were fish tank
cleanings and ping-pong games at Bell’s home. Creed considered herself a
“middle-class Jewish woman” who happily wrote songs in between changing diapers
and cooking. She was also the ultimate anti-star who went out of her way not
flaunt her songwriting prowess:
"The neighbors knew she
was in the record business, but they had no idea what she did. She was content
to be the cook in the kitchen rather than the whipped cream on the cake. She'd
be in the dentist's chair and her songs would be playing on Muzak and she wouldn't
tell anyone it was hers. "Every time I tried to tell people, she'd step on
my foot,"
---- husband Stephen Epstein
(1986)
Through
all her successes, Creed’s health issues always loomed in the background. Three
years after her breast cancer diagnosis, she underwent a radical mastectomy. As
always, she pressed on, pen game strong. When Creed breezed into her doctor’s
office in diamonds and a fur coat and all, he marveled at her strength during
the rigorous chemo sessions that would make her sick on the way home (“Pull
over. I gotta throw up”).
Never
one to allow others to see her in pain, sometimes even Creed’s steely veneer
could be penetrated. During a writing session at her home, Bruce Hawes learned
of his old friend’s health condition from her husband. Usually his visits to
the Creed-Epstein home were an upbeat affair. This time he felt a different vibe---especially when he
privately observed Creed having a solemn tearful moment:
“Because of what her husband said to me
earlier, I knew she would never see the horses playing in the meadow she was
looking out at. I could see she knew it too. I noticed her sitting and gazing
out the dining room window. And as she was looking beyond the ranch style fence
at the meadow, I also noticed she was writing on the legal pad with tears in
her eyes…”
When
she reemerged, a ’85 Billboard Magazine trumpeted her arrival (“Songwriter/Producer Returns to Active
Service”). In a younger market dominated by MTV, rap and rock acts, Creed
was not intimidated by the music industry’s climate change. She was right in
synch with mature R&B and contemporary pop ballads targeting a more adult
crowd. She boldly stated her intent to reclaim her spot in the music business:
“I
called companies that I’d done business with over the years and told them I was
very confident of what I could give to the industry. Everyone can’t jump on
Prince’s thing. Its like a pendulum swing. After bam-bam, the love songs will
always be there”.
Creed wrote for various artists in the
Eighties but her songs were especially a boon for old Philly Soul comrade Teddy
Pendergrass. Creed’s Hold Me ---became a Pendergrass ballad that introduced
the world to Whitney Houston. As Pendergrass---the first Black artist with five
consecutive platinum albums until a car accident left him a quadriplegic---
looked to revive his career, Creed became Pendergrass' songwriting mentor. It
would help him generate publishing revenue to offset his loss of lucrative
touring income. Pendergrass went on to enjoy a solid career as a gold-selling
artist. Touched by Creed's support for him as her own condition worsened, he paid
tribute to her in his 1998 memoir Truly
Blessed:
“She was a woman with courageous spirit and
at a time she was faced so many problems of her own she gave so much to me. I realized how much money I was losing
by not writing my own songs, but I wasn’t certain I had what it took to write
songs good enough that I’d want to record them. Linda gets total credit for
pushing me to try. Even when she was clearly losing her battle, she found a way
to a way to cheer me through mine.”
Creed remained close to her Philly comrades, booking time at Sigma Sound Studios for her writing and producing projects. Old partner Bell--- by this time living in Washington State enjoying semi-retirement, reunited with Creed for a series of one-off projects including a final collaboration with singer Phyllis Hyman.
Phyllis Hyman tearfully discusses recording one of Creed's final compositions.
By early ’86 Creed---racked by bone and liver cancer became bedridden. As usual, her mental resolve and strength were ever-present as the end was near:
"I came home one day,
and she was lying on the bed and she said, 'I've got to tell you something
right now. I'm very content. I've lived a full life with you in 15 years. I
don't care if I die. I'm happy, I'm at peace. The only thing I'm going to miss
is hanging around with you. But I know you'll be fine.'
----Stephen Epstein (1986)
Linda Creed was falling into a coma as Whitney
Houston’s version of The Greatest Love of
All headed up back up the charts for the second time, nearly a decade after
its release. On April 10, 1986 Creed passed away as Love closed in on the top spot, losing her battle with cancer at
the young age of 37. Flowers and fruit baskets poured into the Epstein home from
all over the world.
On
the eve of a concert sponsored by the Philadelphia chapter of the Black Music
Association, featuring artists who made Creed’s songs hits - Whitney Houston,
the Stylistics, the Spinners, Phyllis Hyman, Michael Masser and the MFSB
Orchestra paid musical tribute to the late songwriter---Creed’s husband
eulogized his wife, reflecting on her humility and talent during an interview
with the Philadelphia Inquirer:
"Paul McCartney was
dying to meet Creed and she couldn't believe it. . . . She'd say 'Get outta
here, you don't want to meet me.' She didn't realize who she was. . . .She
wrote all these songs changing diapers. "Thommy would give her the melody
and I'd come home, and she would be sitting at the dinner table with our
daughter in a little rocker, with a bottle in one hand and a pencil in the
other….Linda Creed didn't deserve to die like that, because that girl never
hurt or harmed a hair on an ant. This is the hardest thing in my life or my
children's life that we'll ever have to deal with. But my kids are two proud
little girls who rose to the occasion. When Mom passed away, for them, the
relief of not seeing Mommy hurt anymore . . . all the ambulances, stretchers,
doctors, surgery. Now, as much as they miss her, they don't have to see her in
pain.”
Together,
Linda Creed and Thom Bell were awarded 23 gold and platinum records. Many of
the their hundred-plus compositions demonstrate a durable staying power via
films, remakes, reinterpretations and samples in every music genre. Bell
proudly remembered the chemistry they shared in creating modern-day standards:
"Gamble and Huff are
great writers of the soul. Creed and I are great writers of the heart."
There’s a vast difference. It ain’t but about six inches apart, but it’s miles
apart when it comes to feeling.” When we would write, we would be in the
spheres of the air. We would be way out there. Creed lived lyrics, just like I
live melodies. I had a motto: when you hear one of my melodies, I don’t want it
to bounce off your ear, I want it to caress your ear.
When
the likes of Johnny Carson or Mike Douglas came calling for the duo to appear
on their talk shows---the equivalent of becoming a trending topic on social
media---Bell and Creed didn’t budge. They preferred regular lives away from the
business. Even as the cash rolled in, Bell still took public transportation and
Creed preferred a simple life of anonymity away from the music business:
“Tommy and I have turned down
several TV shows because he takes the bus to work every morning and says how
can I take the bus to work if people know who I am? They’ll never leave me
alone. How can I go into Pantry Pride
and go shopping? I will not perform. I will never perform. I am very happy at home. I’d like to be a
mother someday. I want equal balance between my business and home life”.
Bell and Creed let the music speak for them
and the music world listened. Johnny Mathis ventured out to Creed’s home to
have her customize lyrics to accommodate his lisp. R&B/disco songs shot the
Bee Gees into orbit, but the wind beneath their wings were Philly-style ballads
like Too Much Heaven (“we were very influenced by Linda Creed songs like Betcha By Golly Wow and the hit by the
Stylistics---You Make Me Feel Brand New”)
and Love So Right (“we twere rying to be the Delfonics”). Heatwave’s
slow jams like Always and Forever (“melt all my heart away/with a smile”) recreated the Bell-Creed formula. During the 80's their music has been immortalized in TV commercials advertising 70s soul album compilations.
During the 90s and 2000s,You Are Everything turned up in hit R&B songs by Mary J. Blige and Letoya Luckett. Prince covered Betcha By Golly Wow. Hip-hop/R&B’s swagger was retired in favor of next-level millennial emo-soul singers John Legend, Daley, The Weekend and Daley---with a hint of Creed’s sentimental romantic vibe and delivered in Thompkins’ stylistic falsetto. When Bad Boy Records singer/producer Mario Winans sings ”Somebody said they saw you/ the person you were kissing wasn’t me” on 2004's I Don't Wanna Know, its a deja vu homage to Thompkins’ painful revelation of mistaken identity on Bell and Creed’s You Are Everything back in ’71: ”As she turned the corner/ I called out her name/I felt so ashamed/ That it wasn’t you”. In 2017, Bell was presented with the Grammy Awards highest honor---the Trustees Award acknowledging his contributions to American music while Thompkins---in full vocal form---performed classic material written by Bell and Creed.
During the 90s and 2000s,You Are Everything turned up in hit R&B songs by Mary J. Blige and Letoya Luckett. Prince covered Betcha By Golly Wow. Hip-hop/R&B’s swagger was retired in favor of next-level millennial emo-soul singers John Legend, Daley, The Weekend and Daley---with a hint of Creed’s sentimental romantic vibe and delivered in Thompkins’ stylistic falsetto. When Bad Boy Records singer/producer Mario Winans sings ”Somebody said they saw you/ the person you were kissing wasn’t me” on 2004's I Don't Wanna Know, its a deja vu homage to Thompkins’ painful revelation of mistaken identity on Bell and Creed’s You Are Everything back in ’71: ”As she turned the corner/ I called out her name/I felt so ashamed/ That it wasn’t you”. In 2017, Bell was presented with the Grammy Awards highest honor---the Trustees Award acknowledging his contributions to American music while Thompkins---in full vocal form---performed classic material written by Bell and Creed.
Today’s
music industry is congested with commuters on the road to riches navigating the
fast lane in search of fortune and fame. As they travel at the speed of light, Thom
Bell and Linda Creed’s creative feats seem lost in history’s rearview mirror. Thanks
to their timeless body of work, their legacy---in the words of one of their
greatest songs---keeps growing strong.
just wonderful will share
ReplyDeletei LOVE HER AND HER CONTRIBUTIONS TO PHILLY SOUL THE BEST.
ReplyDeleteI remember buying my first album round two stylistics , at the time while studying the back of the album Tom bell registered in my head up to this day.
ReplyDeletethanks for readingh
DeleteThis an awesome study. When I heard "didn't I blow your mind" it struck me as the perfect marriage of soul and classical. It was heartfelt as well as dignified...sad to say much of today's music lacks those elements.
ReplyDeleteI sincerely wish there will be Bell/Creed combos again
This is a good blog, it is very useful for me Bend Personal Injury Attorney
ReplyDeleteWith free consultations, you can talk with us at no obligation. We work on a contingency basis, allowing you to hire us with no financial obligation.